Constructing National Identity in Socialist Yugoslavia and the Issue of Macedonian Church
Keywords:
national identity, Yugoslavia, autocephaly, Macedonian Orthodox Church, SERBIAN Orthodox Church, Josip Broz Tito, national questionAbstract
The article focuses on the influence of the religious factor on the national identity in the post-war Yugoslavia. The main attention is paid to the state policy of supporting some religious institutions with an aim to affect the national question. The other aspect of research is the representation of the religious policy in the context of national memory as reflected in historiography. As a case study the article examines the issue of separation of Macedonian Orthodox Church and proclamation of its autocephaly from the Serbian Orthodox Church in the context of forming the socialist Yugoslavian society and Cold War discourse.Downloads
References
Веселиновић Р. Преглед историjе цркве у Староj Србиjи и Маведониjи од 1766. до 1919-Године. Српска Православна Црква 1219-1969. Београд, 1969
Волокитина Т. В., Мурашко Г. П., Носкова А. Ф., Нохотович Д. Н. (ред.) Власть и церковь в Восточной Европе. 1944-1953. Документы российских архивов. Т. 1, 1944-1948. Москва: РОССПЭН, 2009
Гиренко Ю. С. Советско-югославские отношения. Москва: Международные отношения, 1983
Гришина Р. П. (отв. ред.) Национальный вопрос на Балканах через призму мировой революции: В документах центральных российских архивов начала середины 1920-х годов. Ч. 1, Москва: Эдиториал УРСС, 2000
Гуськова Е. Ю. Геополитический аспект конфликта Сталин - Тито [http://guskova. ru/w/yuhis/2009-dec, доступ от 01.09.2014]
Гуськова Е.Ю. (сост.) Македония: Путь к самостоятельности. Документы. Москва: Радуга, 1997
Джилас М. Лицо тоталитаризма. Москва: Новости, 1992
Джуретич В. Развал Югославии в ХХ веке (основные течения 1918-2003). Москва: Индрик, 2003
Jaнковић М. Д. Патријарх Герман у животу и борби за спомен-храм. Београд, 2001
Жила Л., Поповски В. Македонский вопрос в документах Коминтерна Т. 1. Часть 1, 2: 1923-1925 гг. Скопье: Гурга, 1999
Илиевски Д. Смислата на некои отпори против автокефалијата на Македонската православна црква. Скопје: Институт за национална история, 1970
Коминтерн и идея мировой революции. Документы. Москва: Наука, 1998
Косик В.И. Македония -споры, соглашения, войны // На путях к Югославии: за и против. Очерки истории национальных идеологий югославянских народов конец XVIII - начало XX в. Москва: Индрик, 1999
Лотоцький О. Автокефалiя, в 2 т. Варшава: Працi українського наукового iнституту, 1935
Романенко С. Между «пролетарским интернационализмом» и «славянским братством». Российско-югославские отношения в контексте этнополитических конфликтов в Средней Европе (начало ХХ века - 1991 год). Москва: Новое литературное обозрение, 2011
Слијепчевић Ђ. Македонско црквено питање. Минхен, 1969
Слијепчевић Ђ. Питање Македонске православне цркве у Југославији. München, 1959
Снегаров И. История на Охридската архиепископия, в 2. т. (от основания до ликвидации в 1767 г.). София: Академично издательство проф. Марин Дринов, 1995
Спиваковский Е. Н., Груздева В. П. III Конгресс Коминтерна и коммунистическое движение в Болгарии, Румынии и Югославии // Третий конгресс Коминтерна. Москва: Политиздат, 1975. С. 562-623
Тито Б. Избранные статьи и речи. Москва: Полит. лит., 1973
Христов А. Т. ВМРОимакедонската државност 1893-1934. Скопје: Култура, 1993
«Relations between the state and the Roman Catholic Church in Croatia, Yugoslavia in the 1970s and 1980s» (1982), Occasional papers on religion in Eastern Europe 2 (3)
Akhavan, P. Howse, R. (1995) Yugoslavia: The Former and Future, Reflections by Scholars from the Region. Washington D. C.: Brookings Institute
Alexander, S. (1979) Church and State in Yugoslavia since 1945. Cambridge: University Press
Alexander, S. (1987) The Triple Myth. A Life of Archbishop Alojzije Stepinac. N. Y.: Columbia University Press
Altevolmer, B. (2004) Nation-Building in Serbien und Kroatien. Eine Studie zur Reichweite allgemeiner Theorien des Nationalismus. Stuttgart
Banac, I. (1984) The National Question in Yugoslavia. London: Cornell University Press
Benigar, A. (1974) Alojzije Stepinac, Hrvatski Kardinal. Rim
Benson, L. (2001) Yugoslavia: a Concise History. New York: Palgrave Macmillan
Biondich, M. (2006) «We Were Defending the State: Nationalism, Myth and Memory in Twentieth-Century Croatia», in Ideologies and National Identities, pp. 66-70. Budapest
Boeckh, K. (1996) «Monolog der Ideologie: der Prozeß gegen Erzbischof Stepinac 1946 in der damaligen jugoslawischen Presse», F. Prcela (ed.) Dialog. Auf dem Weg zur Wahrheit und zum Glauben, ss. 325-335. Mainz: Paderborn
Bosnjak, B., Bahtijarevic, S. (1969) Socijalisticko drustvo, crkva i religija. Zagreb: Institut za drustvena istrazivanja Sveucilista
Buchenau, K. (2006) Kämpfende Kirchen: Jugoslawiens religiöse Hypothek. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang
Buchenau, K. (2003) «Was ist nur falsch gelaufen? Überlegungen zum Kirche-Staat-Verhältnis im sozialistischen Jugoslawien», Lehmann, H., Schjorring, J. H. (eds) Im Räderwerk des «real existierenden Sozialismus». Kirchen in Ostmittel- und Osteuropa von Stalin bis Gorbatschow. Göttingen: Wallstein Verlag
Cepreganov, T. Shashko, Ph. (2010) «The Macedonian Orthodox Church», in Leustean, L. N. (ed.) Eastern Christianity and the Cold War, pp. 173-188. London: Routledge
Cviic, C. (1985) «Religion and Nationalism in Eastern Europe: the Case of Yugoslavia», Journal of international studies 14 (2)
Cvitkovic, I. (1986) Ko je bio Alojzije Stepinac. Sarajevo: NISRO Oslobodjenje
Cvitkovic, I. (1981) «Crkva u savremenom jugoslavenskom drustvu», Nase teme 25 (7/8)
Djilas, M. (1992) Lico totalitarizma [The face of the totalitarism]. Moscow: Novosti
Djuretic, V. (2003) Razval Jugoslavii v XX veke (osnovnie techenia 1918-2003). [Destroying of Yugoslavia in the 20th century (the main directions 1918-2003)]. Moscow: Indrik
Döpmann, H.-D. (2006) Kirche in Bulgarien von den Anfängen bis zur Gegenwart. München: Biblion-Verlag
Drobech, W., Stauber, R., Tropper, P. G. (2007) Mensch, Staat und Kirchen zwischen Alpen und Adria 1848-1938. Einblicke in Religion, Politik, Kultur und Wirtschaft einer Übergangszeit. Klagenfurt/Celovec-Ljubljana/Laibach-Wien/Dunaj; Klagenfurt
Frid, Z. (1971) Religija u samoupravnom socijalizmu. Zagreb: Centar za drustvene djelatnosti omladine
Gallagher, T. (2000) The Balkans after the Cold War: From Tyranny to Tragedy. London: Routledge
Gallagher, T. (2005) The Balkans in the New Millenium. In the Shadow of War and Peace. New York
Gelzer, H. (1902) Der Patriarchat von Achrida. Geschichte und Urkunden. Leipzig
Girenko, Yu. (1983) Sovetsko-yugoslavske otnoshenia [Soviet-Yugoslav relationship]. Moscow
Greinacher, N, Elizondo, V. (1982) Churches in Socialist Societies of Eastern Europe. New York
Grishina, R. P. (2000) Nacionalniy vopros na Balkanah cherez prizmu mirovoj revolucii: V dokumentah centralnih rossijskih arhivov nachala serediny 1920-h godov [National question in the Balkans through the prism of the world revolution: In documents from the central Russian archives from the middle of the 1920s], Vol. 1, Moscow
Guskova, E. (2009) Geopoliticheskij aspekt konflikta Stalin-Tito [Geo-political aspect of Stalin-Tito's conflict] [http://guskova.ru/ w/yuhis /2009-dec, accessed on 01.09.2014]
Guskova, E. (1997) Makedonija: Put k samostojatelnosti. Dokumenti [Macedonia: the way to the independency. Documents]. Moscow
Hatzopoulos, P. (2008) Balkans beyond Nationalism and Identity. International Relations and Ideology. London
Hristov, A. (1993) VMROimakedonskata drzavnost 1893-1934 [VMRO and Macedonian statehood]. Skopje
Hudson, K. (2003) Breaking the South Slav Dream, The Rise and Fall of Yugoslavia. London
Ilievski, D. (1970) Smislata na nekoi otpori protiv avtokefalijata na Makedonskata pravoslavna crkva [The meaning of the resistence against autocephaly of Macedonian Orthodox Church]. Skopje
Jankovic, M. D. (2001) Patrijarh German u zivotu i borbi za spomen-hram. Beograd
Jerotic, V. (2004) Vera i nacija. Beograd: Ars Libri
Jovic, D. (2006) «Communist Yugoslavia and Its ‘Others’”, in J. R. Lampe and M. Mazower (eds) Ideologies and National Identities. Budapest
Komintern i ideja mirovoj revolucii. Dokumenti [Comintern and the idea of the world revolution] (1998). Moscow: Nauka
Kosik, V. I. (1997) «Makedonija - spori, soglashenija, vojni» [Macedonia - conflicts, agreements, wars], in Naputiah k Jugoslavii: za iprotiv. Ocherki istorii nacionalnih ideologij jugoslavianskih narodov 18 - nachala 20 v. [On the way to Yugoslavia: pro et contra. Apects of the history of national ideologies of Yugoslavian nations 18 - beginning of the 20th c.]. Moscow
Kristo, I. (1997) Katolicka crkva u totalitarizmu 1945.-1990.: razmatranja o Crkvi u Hrvatskoj pod komunizmom. Zagreb
Leustan L. N. (2004) «Religious Elements in Defining European Identity in the European Union and Southeastern Europe», in D. Marinovic, S. Zrinscak, I. Borowik (eds) Religion and patterns of social transformation, pp.277-295. Zagreb
Lotockiy, O. (1935) Avtokefalia [Autocephaly]. Warsaw
Manousakis, G. M. (1997) «Das Verhältnis von Orthodoxie und Islam im heutigen Südosteuropa», in Döpmann, H.-D. (Hg.) Religion und Gesellschaft in Südosteuropa. München
Milinkovic, B. (1992) Bibliografija radova o nacionalnom pitanju i medunacionalnim odnosima. Zagreb
Mojzes, P. (1987) Church and State in Postwar Eastern Europe. A Bibliographical Survey. New York: Greenwood Press
Mojzes, P. (1992) Religious Liberty in Eastern Europe and the USSR. Before and After the Great Transformation. New York
Mojzes, P. (1994) Yugoslavian Inferno. Ethnoreligious warfare in the Balkans. New York
Muzic, I. (1978) Katolicka crkva u Kraljevini Jugoslaviji. Split
Nikolic, M., Dimitrijevic, D. (2013) "‘Macedonian Orthodox Church (MOC) ' in Former Yugoslav State», The Politics and Religion Journal 7 (1): 193-215 [http://www. politicsandreligionjournal.com/images/pdf_files/engleski/volume7_no1/nikolic. pdf, accessed on 20.12.2014]
«Odnosi izmedju vjerskih zajednica i drzave» (1981), Argumenti 1 (1): 80-103
Okey, R. (2007) Taming Balkan Nationalism, The Habsburg «Civilizing Mission» in Bosnia, 1878-1914. New York
Pavlowitch, S. K. (1990) The Improbable Survivor. Yugoslavia and its Problems 1918-1988. London
Pavlowitch, S. K. (2008) Hitler’s New Disorder. The Second World War in Yugoslavia. London
Perica, V. (2002) Balkan Idols: Religion and Nationalism in Yugoslav States. Oxford
Petranovic, B., Zecevic, M. (eds) (1988) Jugoslavija 1918-1988. Tematska zbirka dokumenata. Beograd
Petrovic, M. (1997) Konkordatsko pitanje Kraljevine Srba, Hrvata i Slovenaca. Beograd
Podskalsky, G. (1997) «Zwei Erzbischöfe von Achrida (Ochrid) und ihre Bedeutung für die Profan- und Kirchengeschichte Mazedoniens: Theophylaktos und Demetrios Chomatenos», in La spiritualité de l'univers byzantin dans le verbe et Vimage (Festschrift für E. Voordeckers). Turnhout
Prinzing, G. (1993) «Ohrid», Lexikon des Mittelalters 6: 1376-1380
Ramet, S. P. (1984) «The Interplay of Religious Policy and Nationalist Policy in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe», Religion and Nationalism in Soviet and East European Politics. Durham
Ramet, S. P. (2011) Die drei Jugoslawien. Eine Geschichte der Staatsbildungen und ihrer Probleme. München
Romanenko, S. (2011) Mezhdu «proletarskim internacionalizmom» i «slavjanskim bratstvom». Rossijsko-jugoslavskie otnoshenija v kontekste etnopoliticheskih konfliktov v Srednej Evrope (nachalo XX veka - 1991 god) [Between «proletarian internationalism» and «Slav brotherhood». Russian-Yugoslavian relations in the context of ethno-political conflicts in the Central Europe (beginning of the 20th century - 1991)]. Moscow
Roter, Z. (1976) Katoliska cerkev in drzava v Jugoslaviji 1945-1973. Socioloski teoreticni vidiki in raziskovalni model. Ljubljana
Sagi-Bunic, Т. (1983) Katolicka crkva i hrvatski narod. Zagreb
Slijepcevic, D. (1959) Pitanje Makedonske pravoslavne crkve u Jugoslaviji. München
Slijepcevic, D. (1969) Makedonsko crkveno pitanje. München
Slijepcevic, D. (2002) Istorija Srpske Pravoslavne Crkve, 2. Beograd
Snegarov, I. (1995) Istorija na Ohridskata arhiepiskopia (ot osnovania do likvidacii v 1767 g.) [History of the Ohrid archdiocease (from founding till liquidation in 1767)]. Sofia
Spivakovskij, E., Gruzdeca, V. (1975) «III Kongress Kominterna i kommunisticheskoe dvizhenie v Bolgarii, Rumynii i Jugoslavii» [III Congress of Comintern and the communist movement in Bulgaria, Romania and Yugoslavia], Tretij kongress Kominterna [The Third Congress of Comintern], pp. 562-623. Moscow
Stojadinovic, M. M. (1970) Ni rat ni pakt. Jugoslavija izmedju dva rata. Rijeka-Opatija: Otokar Kersovani
Tito, B. (1973) Izbrannie statji i rechi [Selected articles and speeches]. Moscow
Todorova, M. (2009) Imagining the Balkans. New York
Udovicki, J., Ridgeway, J. (2000) Burn This House. The Making and Unmaking of Yugoslavia. London
Velikonja, M. (2003) Religious Separation and Political Intolerance in Bosnia Herzegovina. Texas
Veselinovic, R. (1969) «Pregled istorije crkve u Staroj Srbiji i Makedoniji od 1766. Do 1919. Godine», Srpska Pravoslavna Crkva 1219-1969. Beograd: zdanje Svetog arhijerejskog sinoda Srpske pravoslavne crkve
Vidic, R. (1962) Position of the Church in Yugoslavia. Belgrade
Volokitina, T., Murashko, G., Noskova, A. (2008) Moskva i Vostochnaia Evropa. Vlast' i tserkov' v period obshchestvennykh transformatsii 40-50 godov XX v. [Moscow and Eastern Europe. The Power and the Church in the Period of Society's Transformations in the 1940s and 1950s]. Moscow
Vrcan, S. (1980) Raspeto katolicanstvo. Zagreb
Vuskovic, B. Placko, Lj. (1987) «Religijsko-crkvena identifikacija i praksa», Religija i drustvo. Zagreb
Zila, L., Popovski, V. (1999) Makedonskij vopros v dokumentah Kominterna [Macedonian question in the documents of Comintern], vol. 1, part 1, 2: 1923-1925. Skopje: Gurga
Zirdum, A. (2007) Povijest krscanstva u Bosni i Herzegovini. Plehan: Slovoznak
Zrinscak, S. (1999) Sociologija religije. Hrvatsko iskustvo. Zagreb: Pravni fakultet
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
How to Cite
Коды статьи
- EDN THGDJZ
- Тип статьи (РИНЦ) Научная статья (Научная статья)
