The Panorthodox Council: Shaping New Orthodox Geopolitics
Keywords:
Pan-Orthodox Council, orthodox church, geopolitics, identity, territory, diasporaAbstract
The Orthodox Church is a complex geopolitical reality, and it does not constitute a homogenous block. On the contrary, the rise of irredentism during the 19th century has created the basis for constant territorial fragmentation throughout the 20th century. Surprisingly, the worldwide Orthodox population continues to increase. The convergence of these two phenomena is a starting point for a reinvestigation of Orthodox power in international affairs, as well as a profound strategic change affecting the communion of the fourteen local Orthodox Churches. This article examines how Orthodoxy, through the process of convening a Holy and Great Council, has responded to geopolitics by developing new approaches and new Orthodoxy identities; how the territorial changes affected their strategies in the Diaspora; what was their role in new international conflicts. The first part of the article deals with an epistemological approach to place Orthodoxy in the context of geopolitical studies, while the second part highlights the persistence of a bipolar paradigm opposing the Patriarchates of Constantinople and Moscow. Finally, the paper considers geopolitical challenges for Orthodoxy created by today’s politico-religious crisis in Syria.Downloads
References
Флоровский Г. Пути русского богословия. Париж, 1937
Afanasiev N. (1975) L'Eglise du Saint-Esprit. Paris: Editions du Cerf
Anastassiadou M., Dumont, P. (2011) Les Grecs d'Istanbul et le patriarcat œcuménique au seuil du 21e siècle: une communauté en quête d'avenir. Paris: Cerf
Arjakovsky A. (2013) Qu'est-ce que l'orthodoxie. Paris: Gallimard
Clément O. (1976) Dialogue avec le patriarche Athénagoras. Paris: Fayard
Colosimo J.-F. (2015) Les hommes en trop. Paris: Fayard
Colosimo J.-F. (2007) "Bloc Note", Orthodoxie [http://www.orthodoxie.com/non-classe/bloc-notes-de-1-3/, accessed on 08.12.2015]
Colosimo J.-F. (2010) “Métamorphose du divin”, Le Débat 160: 79-93
Sardes M. de (1975) Le Patriarcat œcuménique dans l'Eglise orthodoxe: étude historique et canonique. Paris: Beauchesne
Florovsky G. (1937) Puti russkogo bogosloviia [Ways of Russian theology]. Paris
Fokas E. (2014) “Pluralism and Religious Freedom in Majority Orthodox Contexts”, Working Paper 49 (Athens: ELIAMEP)
Fukuyama F. (1992) The end of History and the last man. New York: The free press
Hass R. (2008) “The Age of Nonpolarity”, Foreign Affairs
[https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2008-05-03/age-nonpolarity, accessed, 15.12.2015]
Holy Synod of the Greek Orthodox Patriarchate of Antioch and All the East (2014) «Communiqué", Orthodoxie [http://www.orthodoxie.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/CommuniquéSessionExtraordinaireSaintSynodeDuPatriarcatGrecOorthodoxeAntiocheAvril2014.pdf, accessed on 09.12.2015]
Holy Synod of the Russian Orthodox Church. (2013) "Position du Patriarcat de Moscou au sujet de la primauté dans l'Eglise universelle", numéro de protocole 157, Orthodoxie [http://www.orthodoxie.com/actualites/position-du-patriarcat-de-moscou-au-sujet-de-la-primaute-dans-leglise-universelle/, accessed on 08.12.2015]
Huntington S. (1996) The Clash of Civilizations and the remaking of world order. New York: Simon & Schuster
Huntington S. (1993) "The Clash of Civilizations?", Foreign Affairs (Summer) [https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/1993-06-01/clash-civilizations, accessed on 08.12.2015]
Kaluzny T. (2012) “The History at the Present Stage of the Preparations for the PanOrthodox Council”, Studia Oecumenica 12: 153-160
Kazarian N. (2015) “The Orthodox Church in France facing French secularism (‘laïcité’)”, Religion, State and Society 43/3: 244-261
Kazarian N. (2014) “Orthodox Diplomacy” of Patriarch Kirill”, in Dubien, A. (ed.) Russia 2014: The View from the Observatoire Franco-Russe, p. 398-407. Paris: Cherche midi
Kazarian N. (2013) “Chypre, les enjeux géopolitiques de l’axe orthodoxe ”, La Nouvelle Revue Géopolitique 122: 51-57
Kazarian N. (2012) “Orthodoxie et mondialisation, une résistance en mouvement: Étude des paradigmes grecs et russes”, in Massignon, B., Grannec, C. (eds.) Les religions dans la mondialisation: entre acculturation et contestation, p. 125-146. Paris: Editions Karthala
Krindatch, A. (2011) Atlas of American Orthodox Christian Churches, Brookline (MA): Holy Cross Orthodox Press
Mahieu P. (2012) Paul VI et les orthodoxes. Paris: Cerf
Mämmerli M., Mayer, J.-F. (eds) (2014) Orthodox Identities in Western Europe: migration, settlement and innovation. Farnham, Surrey; Burlington: Ashgate
Massignon B. (2005) “Les représentations orthodoxes auprès de l’Union européenne: entre concurrence inter-orthodoxe et dynamique d’européanisation”, Balkanologie 9 (1-2): 265-287
Patriarchate of Antioch (August 2015) «Communiqué ", Orthodoxie [http://orthodoxie.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Com_Antioche_Qatar.pdf, accessed on 09.12.2015]
Patriarchate of Jerusalem (2015) "The position of the Patriarchate of Jerusalem on the interruption of communion by the Patriarchate of Antioch", Jerusalem Patriarchate Official News Gate [http://www.jp-newsgate.net/en/2015/07/10/15575, accessed on 09.12.2015]
Patriarchate of Moscow (2011) "His Holiness Patriarch Kirill meets with President of Syria Bashar al-Assad", Department for the external relations of the Moscow Patriarchate [https://mospat.ru/en/2011/11/14/news52135/, accessed on 09.12.2015]
Pew Research Center (2011) "Table: Christian Population in Numbers by Country", Pew Research Center [http://features.pewforum.org/global-christianity/population-number.php, accessed on 09.12.2015]
Pnevmatikakis V. (2014) La géopolitique de la diaspora orthodoxe en France: territoire, pouvoir, identité. Ph.D. Thesis. University of Paris 8
Pnevmatikakis V. (2013) La territorialité de lEglise orthodoxe en France, entre exclusivisme juridictionnel et catholicité locale (Carnets de géographes 6), Carnets de Géographes [http://www.carnetsdegeographes.org/carnets_recherches/rech_06_04_Prevmatikakis.php, accessed, 15.12.2016]
Prévélakis G. (1997) Géopolitique de la Grèce. Bruxelles: Ed. Complexe
Prévélakis G. (1994) Balkans. Cultures et géopolitique. Paris: Nathan
Roudometof V. (2011) “The Evolution of Greek Orthodoxy in the Context of World Historical Globalization”, in Roudometof V., Makrides V.N. (eds.) Orthodox Christianity in 21st Century Greece, p. 21-38. Farnham: Ashgate
Rousselet K. (2013) Sécularisation et orthodoxie dans la Russie contemporaine: pour une hypothèse continuiste?, Questions de recherche 42:16
Rousselet K. (2001) “Globalisation et territoire religieux en Russie”, in Bastian, J.-P., Champion, F., Rousselet, K. (eds.) La Globalisation du Religieux, p. 183-196. Paris: L’Harmattan
Russian Orthodox Church in France (2013) "Message du Patriarche Cyrille de Moscou au Président des États-Unis Barack Obama à propos de la situation en Syrie", Église Orthodoxe Russe en France [http://www.egliserusse.eu/Message-du-Patriarche-Cyrille-de-Moscou-au-President-des-Etats-Unis-Barack-Obama-a-propos-de-la-situation-en-Syrie_a1303.html, accessed on 08.12.2015]
Sfeir A. (2011) “La France ne défendant plus les chrétiens d’Orient, la Russie a pris le relais”, Atlantico, November 21
Schmemann A. (1960) "La notion de primauté dans l'ecclésiologie orthodoxe", in La Primauté de Pierre dans l′Eglise orthodoxe. Neuchatel: Editions Delachaux & Niestlé
Spengler O. (1918-1922) Der Untergang des Abendlandes. Vienna/Munich: Verlag C.H. Beck
Synaxis of Primates of Orthodox Autocephalous Churches. (2014) "Communiqué", Orthodox Christian Network [http://myocn.net/ecumenical-patriarchate/, accessed on 30.12.2015]
Thual Fr. (1998) Le douaire de Byzance - Territoires et identities de l′Orthodoxie. Paris: Ellipses
Thual Fr. (1993) Géopolitique de l'orthodoxie. Paris: Dunod
Zizioulas J. (2001) Eucharist, Bishop, Church - The Unity of the Church in the Divine Eucharist and the Bishop During the First Three Centuries. Boston: Holy Cross Orthodox Press
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
How to Cite
Коды статьи
- EDN VSYYPH
- Тип статьи (РИНЦ) Научная статья (Научная статья)