Multiple Modernities, Russias Cursed Issues and the Endurance of Secular Modernity (a Theoretical Essay)
Keywords:
post-secular, russia, multiple modernities, secularismAbstract
Russia provides interesting material to test Eisentadt's hypothesis of 'multiple modernities' and the idea that such alleged 'multiplicity' is determined by the differences of religious traditions. I argue that in Russia all attempts at modernization, starting from Peter the Great and including its Soviet version, were oriented towards the western 'cultural program of modernity', as an ideal type, rather than toward creating some special 'Russian pattern' of it. I also believe that secularism has always been and continues to be an inalienable part of this 'western modernity', and therefore, in Russia, all Christian Orthodox discourses and religiously-inspired movements led not so much to the encoding of modernity with some special religious meanings, but rather to implicit modernization, or adaptation of religion itself- even in spite of Russian Orthodoxy's explicitly antimodern posture. Overall, my perception is that some widespread interpretations of Eisenstadt's idea go a way too far towards emphasizing multiplicity, and that the concept of 'postsecular' should be used very cautiously.Downloads
References
См. Лотман Ю.М., Успенский Б.А. Роль дуальных моделей в динамике русской культуры (до конца XVIII века) // Труды по рус. и слав. филологии. Т. 28. Тарту, 1977
Ахиезер А. Россия. Критика исторического опыта (социокультурная динамика России). М.: Новый хронограф, 2008
См., например: Ильин В. В., Панарин А. С., Ахиезер А. С. Реформы и контрреформы в России: Циклы модернизации процесса. М.: Издательство Московского университета, 1996.
О советском периоде см.: Christian D. Imperial and Soviet Russia: Power, Privilege and the Challenge of Modernity. Basingstoke: Palgrave / Macmillan, 1997; Suny R. The Soviet Experiment: Russia, the USSR, and the Successor States. London and New York: Oxford University Press, 1998; Poe M. The Russian Moment in World History. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2006.
Walitsky A. The Slavophile Controversy: History of a Conservative Utopia in Nineteenth-century Russian Thought. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1975.
Wagner P. A Sociology of Modernity: Liberty and Discipline. London and New York: Routledge, 1994.
Eisenstadt S. N. Multiple Modernities // Daedalus. 2000. Vol. 129 (1). P. 9.
Eisenstadt S. N. Multiple Modernities.
Бердяев Н.А. Истоки и смысл русского коммунизма. М.: Наука, 1990.
Arnason J. Communism and Modernity // Daedalus. 2000. Vol. 129 (4). P. 61 - 90.
Об этом лучше всего писал Энтони Гидденс: Giddens A. Modernity and Self-identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1991.
Eisenstadt S.N. Multiple Modernities // Daedalus. 2000. Vol. 129 (1). P. 3.
Arnason J. Communism and Modernity // Daedalus. 2000. Vol. 129 (4). P. 63.
Wagner P. Modernity as Experience and Interpretation. A New Sociology of Modernity. Oxford: Polity Press, 2008.
Eisenstadt S. N. Multiple Modernities. P. 7 - 8.
Arnason J. Communism and Modernity. P. 65.
См. Фуко М. Надзирать и наказывать. Рождение тюрьмы. М.: Ad Marginem, 1999; Агамбен Дж. Homo Sacer. Суверенная власть и голая жизнь. М.: Европа, 2011
Eisenstadt S. N. Multiple Modernities. P. 22.
Bourdieu P. Language and Symbolic Power. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1991.Религия и множественные современности 94
Arnason J. Communism and Modernity. P. 64.
Сonnolly W. Why I Am Not a Secularist. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1999.
См. обсуждение: Warner S. Work in Progress toward a New Paradigm for the Sociological Study of Religion in the United States // American Journal of Sociology. 1993. Vol. 98 (5). P. 1044 - 1093; Calhoun G. Afterword: Religion's Many Powers // The Power of Religion in the Public Sphere (Eds. E. Mendieta and J.Van Antwerpen). N. Y.: Collumbia University Press, 2011. P. 118-134.
Religion in the Public Sphere (Eds. E. Mendieta and J. Van Antwerpen). N. Y: Columbia University Press, 2011. P. 118 - 134.
Sorkin D. The Religious Enlightenment. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2008.
Gillespie G. The Theological Origins of Modernity. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2009.
Cм.: Casanova J. Public Religion in the Modern World. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994; Casanova J. Rethinking Secularization: a Global Comparative Perspective // Hedgehog Review. 2006. Vol. 8 (1-2). P. 7 - 22; Berger P. (ed.) The Desecularization of the World: Resurgent Religion and World Politics. NY: Wm. B. Erdmans Publishing Company, 1999; Martin D. On Secularization: Toward a Revised General Theory. London: Ashgate, 2005.
Сasanova J. Rethinking Secularization: a Global Comparative Perspective // Hedgehog Review. 2006. Vol. 8 (1-2). P. 7 - 22.
Asad T. Genealogies of Religion. Disciplines and Reasons of Power in Christianity in Islam. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1993.
Сasanova J. Rethinking Secularization: a Global Comparative Perspective. P. 10.
Metz J. Christliche Anthropozentrik: über die Denkform des Thomas von Aquin. Munich: Közel Verlag, 1962; Levingston J., Fiorenza F. Modern Christian Thought. Vol. II, Twentieth Century. Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall, 2000; Милбанк Дж. Политическая теология и новая наука политики // Логос. 2008. № 4. С. 33 - 54.
Hefner R. Christianity, Islam, and Hinduism in a Globalizing Age // Annual Review of Anthropology. 1998. Vol. 27. P. 84 - 104.
Taylor Сh. A Secular Age. Сambridge, MA, and London: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2007.
О "сплетенных современностях" см.: Therborn G. Entangled Modernities // European Journal of Social Theory. 2003. Vol. 6 (3). P. 293 - 305; Stoeckl K. Europes Entangled Modernities // Borders Сonstructed and Deconstructed - Orthodox Christianity in Europe (Ed. Alfons Brüning). Leuven: Peeters, 2011 (Forthcoming).
Zhuk S. Russias Lost Reformation. Peasants, Millenialism, and Radical Sects in Southern Russia and Ukraine, 1830 - 1917. Washington, D. С.: Woodrow Wilson Center Press, 2004; Robson R. Old Believers in Modern Russia. DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press, 2007.
Лавров А. Колдовство и религия в России (1700-1740). М.: Древнехранилище, 2000. C. 60 - 74.
Верт П. Православие, инославие, иноверие: очерки по истории религиозного разнообразия российской империи. М.: Новое литературное обозрение, 2012. C. 124 - 27, 138 - 39.
Бердяев Н.А. Истоки и смысл русского коммунизма. М.: Наука, 1990; Lane С. The Rites of Rulers: Ritual in Industrial Society - The Soviet Сase. Сambridge: Сambridge University Press, 1981; Besançon A. Les Origines intellectuelles du léninisme. Paris: Gallimard, 1977.
Robertson R. Globalization, Modernization, and Postmodernization. The Ambiguous Position of Religion // Religion and Global Order. (Eds. R. Robertson and W. Garrett). N. Y.: Paragon House Publishers, 1991. P. 282.
Cм. Agadjanian A., Rousselet K. Globalization and Identity Discourse in Russian Orthodoxy // Eastern Orthodoxy in a Global Age (Eds. V. Roudometof, A. Agadjanian and J. Pankhurst). Walnut Сreek, СA: Altamira Press, 2005. P. 29 - 57.
Основы социальной концепции Русской Православной Церкви (http://www.mospat. ru / en / doсuments / soсial-сonсepts /, доступ 10.11. 2011).
170Основы учения Русской Православной Церкви о достоинстве, свободе и правах человека (http://www.mospat.ru / index. php? page=41 597, доступ 10.11.2011).
Rawls J. The Idea of an Overlapping Consensus // Oxford Journal of Legal Studies. 1987. Vol. 7 (1). P. 1 - 25.
Хабермас Ю. Вера и знание // Хабермас Ю. Будущее человеческой природы. М.: Весь мир, 2002; Хабермас Ю. Религия и публичность. "Когнитивные предпосылки для "публичного использования разума" религиозных и секулярных граждан // Хабермас Ю. Между натурализмом и религией. Философские статьи. М.: Весь мир, 2011.
Agadjanian A. Breakthrough to Modernity, Apologia for Traditionalism: the Russian Orthodox View of Society and Сulture in Сomparative Perspective // Religion, State and Society. 2003. Vol. 31 (4). P. 327 - 46; Agadjanian A. Liberal Individual and Christian Culture: Russian Orthodox Teaching on Human Rights in Social Theory Perspective // Religion, State and Society. 2010. Vol. 38 (2). P. 97 - 113.Александр Агаджанян №1(30) 2012 105
Kyrlezhev A. The Postsecular Age: Religion and Culture Today // Religion, State, and Society. 2008. Vol. 36 (1). P. 21 - 31.
Taylor Ch. A Secular Age. Cambridge, MA, and London: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2007.
The Power of Religion in the Public Sphere / Eds. E. Mendieta and J. Van Antwerpen. N. Y.: Columbia University Press, 2011.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
How to Cite
Коды статьи
- EDN PCJTRR
- Тип статьи (РИНЦ) Научная статья (Научная статья)
